Discover How We Rank Property Managers
Unveiling Our Proprietary Rating System
Explore the comprehensive methodology behind our property manager rankings, designed to empower owners with transparent and reliable insights.
PM Grade Methodology
Our Mission
PM Grade was created to help rental property owners and real estate investors make more informed decisions when selecting a property management company.
Most online reviews of property managers are written by tenants. While tenant feedback can provide useful insight, it often does not reflect the factors that matter most to property owners. Investors are typically concerned with communication, responsiveness, maintenance oversight, financial reporting, transparency, and overall asset performance.
Our goal is to provide a more balanced perspective by focusing on the ownership experience and creating a platform built specifically for property owners.
Our Commitment to Independence
PM Grade is committed to providing objective information about property management companies.
Property management companies cannot purchase rankings, improve their scores through advertising, or pay to remove reviews. Participation in premium profile programs, advertising opportunities, or profile upgrades does not affect rankings or evaluations.
Our goal is to create a trusted resource where property owners can compare companies based on meaningful information rather than marketing budgets.
How We Evaluate Property Management Companies
PM Grade evaluates companies using a combination of information provided by the company, publicly available information, owner feedback, and platform activity.
Factors that may be considered include:
Communication
How effectively a company communicates with property owners regarding maintenance issues, vacancies, financial reporting, and day-to-day management.
Responsiveness
How quickly and consistently a company responds to owners, prospective clients, and operational issues.
Transparency
The availability and clarity of information regarding services, fees, policies, and management practices.
Maintenance Oversight
A company’s ability to coordinate repairs, manage vendors, and address maintenance issues in a timely and professional manner.
Owner Satisfaction
Feedback provided by property owners regarding their overall experience working with the company.
Profile Completeness
The accuracy and completeness of information available on the company’s PM Grade profile.
PM Grade Methodology
How Reviews Are Verified
PM Grade is committed to maintaining the integrity of owner reviews while protecting reviewer privacy.
Before a review is published, we may take steps to verify that the reviewer has a legitimate ownership interest in a rental property managed by the company being reviewed.
Verification methods may include:
- Confirmation of ownership through publicly available property records
- Verification of property addresses
- Verification of management relationships
- Review of supporting documentation when voluntarily provided
- Direct communication with reviewers when clarification is needed
Verification requirements may vary based on available information and the circumstances of each review.
Verification is intended to confirm that a reviewer has a legitimate relationship to the property management company. Verification does not imply endorsement of the opinions expressed in a review.
Why Verification Matters
Property management companies have a significant impact on investment performance, and review quality matters. PM Grade takes reasonable steps to verify that reviews come from individuals with a legitimate ownership interest in properties managed by the company being reviewed. Our goal is to provide property owners with more reliable insights while maintaining reviewer privacy and platform integrity.
That bridges the gap between the process and the benefit.
Privacy for Property Owners
Protecting Reviewer Privacy
Property owners should be able to share their experiences without fear of unwanted solicitation or disclosure.
PM Grade does not sell reviewer information, share contact information with property management companies, or provide reviewer data to third parties for marketing purposes.
Information collected during the review process is used solely to help verify authenticity and maintain the integrity of the platform.
Our goal is to protect reviewers while creating a more transparent property management industry.
How Rankings Work
As PM Grade grows and additional review data becomes available, rankings may be developed to help property owners compare companies within a specific market.
Rankings are intended to provide a general comparison tool and should not be considered endorsements or guarantees of future performance.
Rankings may consider factors such as:
- Verified owner feedback
- Responsiveness
- Transparency
- Profile completeness
- Market presence
- Overall owner experience
Methodologies may evolve over time as additional data becomes available and the platform continues to improve.
Claiming a Profile
Company Profiles and Claiming Listings
Many property management companies are added to PM Grade through independent research and publicly available information.
Companies may claim their profiles to:
- Update business information
- Add company descriptions
- Respond to reviews
- Earn verification badges
- Maintain accurate profile information
Claiming a profile does not impact rankings, review visibility, or evaluation outcomes.
Our Commitment to Transparency
PM Grade was built for property owners and real estate investors.
We believe property owners deserve access to independent information, owner-focused reviews, and transparent evaluation standards when selecting a property management company.
As the platform grows, we will continue to refine our processes, improve our methodology, and remain committed to providing a trusted resource for property owners across the country.
Investor Privacy Promise
Your information belongs to you.
PM Grade was built to help property owners make informed decisions—not to generate sales leads. We do not sell reviewer information, share contact details with property management companies, or allow third parties to solicit investors who contribute reviews.
Any information collected during the review process is used solely to verify the authenticity of reviews and protect the integrity of the platform. Your feedback helps other property owners. Your personal information remains private.
✓ We never sell reviewer information
✓ We never share contact details with property managers
✓ We never allow review-based solicitation
✓ We verify reviews while protecting reviewer privacy